A gift from Lightmakers

The Agency Scorecard.

The 10 questions top brands ask before they hire anyone. Use it on any agency, including us.

01

Have they done this for a brand like yours?

Ask for case studies with real numbers, from brands in your category or at your level.

02

Can they show receipts?

Look for links to press, posts, and recaps you can click yourself, not screenshots.

03

Do they measure sales, or just reach?

Reach gets seen. Sales get budgets renewed. Ask how they connect the work to revenue.

04

Who's senior on your project?

Ask who leads the strategy, and who is on the team behind them.

05

Do they understand your buyer?

Notice whether they talk about your customer before they talk about their services.

06

Is the scope clear?

You should know exactly what you get, and when, before you sign.

07

Do they stand behind it?

Look for a guarantee, or at least a clear commitment in writing.

08

How fast do they respond?

Clients rank professionalism, collaboration, and timeliness at the top of what they want from an agency. Watch how they handle the first week.

09

Do they bring new ideas?

It is the quality clients say they most want more of from their agencies. Ask what they would do that you have not thought of.

10

Do you trust them in a room?

One industry survey found that chemistry always wins over capability. Picture them in front of your press, your partners, your boss.

Your agency scored 0 out of 10. Check each question they pass.

Print or save as PDF →

From Karen Diaz, founder of Lightmakers. Before Lightmakers, Karen spent years at IBM and Gartner, the firm known for grading vendors so companies can choose well. Sources for questions 8 to 10: Setup Marketing Relationship Survey, 2022.

Curious how we score?

Let's talk about your launch.